It’s 3 AM. The blue light from the monitor paints my face in sickly hues as I stare at the sentence again: “Sometimes struggles with executive presence.” My finger hovers over the trackpad, a phantom tremor. I’ve read it 49 times now, maybe more. Was it Susan from marketing? Or perhaps Dave, who always looks at me like I just told him his tie was on fire? The words themselves aren’t particularly damning, not overtly. But in the hushed, polite language of the 360 review, “struggles with executive presence” is a shiv, disguised as a gentle suggestion. It’s designed to stick, to fester, to chip away at the very promotion I’ve been working towards for the last 9 months. My stomach churns, a familiar tightening sensation that has become a constant companion during this annual corporate ritual.
The Shiv
The Wait
The Churn
We’re told, with earnest smiles and carefully crafted HR slides, that these 360-degree reviews are for “development.” A chance to gain valuable insights, to grow, to see ourselves through the eyes of our peers, direct reports, and superiors. What a perfectly curated, corporate-speak delusion. The reality, as anyone who has navigated more than a single cycle knows, is far grittier. It’s an institutionalized system for score-settling, a bureaucratic outsourcing of difficult managerial duties, all meticulously disguised as objective